Book Review: The Cryptographer by Alice Wallis-Eton

The Cryptographer (Second Sons Book 1)The Cryptographer by Alice Wallis-Eton
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

There is something so fun about a bit of historical romance that also has the best spying and code breaking intertwined. The Cryptographer is just that. The story of an intelligent, gifted woman, Aster Tanner, that works for a living in the war department. She loves puzzles and her boss, Sir John, keeps providing codes for her to break that are becoming more than just fun and games to stimulate her mind.

When Iain comes to the small town where she works she finds herself attracted to him. Iain also struggles with his desire to know more about this simple woman. No one knows that she is the assistant or secretary to Sir John since that is an unusual position for a woman of the time. When Captain Iain McIntyre comes into the room, she is caught off guard and spills this secret right away. Now she fears she has placed herself in danger. The romance is sweet and hopeful. The spying details are in depth and altogether it makes for a lovely read.

My favorite quote from the book is actually the very first words of the book. It shows the humor that is going to be interwoven with the romance and the intrigue.

“Dougal, your breath is disgusting.” The noxious odour assaulted Aster’s nose, rousing her from sleep. She screwed up her face and rolled over, but the smell leapt over her and continued its assault. “Honestly,”

Iain and his three friends and fellow Scots Greys are personable and basically adorable scotsmen. They are part of the Second Dragoons helping the English in their war against France through spying and code breaking. I liked the side characters Aibme, Seamus and Quinn, the soldiers in Iain’s troop. Each have a unique personality that makes them a pleasure to read about. Aunt Margaret is great too. She is an over the top feisty aunt and she is a wonderful addition.

I loved Iain and his desire to protect and get to know more about Aster. This is a book I can recommend if you like historical Romances. As a debut novel it has great story plot and I found very little not to like about it. There was healthy suspicion between the main characters and their search for the truth before they could trust each other, they both had to earn it. I liked that. It gave it a realistic feel. It is how I would expect people to behave when dealing with spies, coded notes and potential assassins.

I did notice that some of the other reviewers on Goodreads and Amazon thought that it was not in keeping with the era, but I did not find that to be the case. Perhaps they had an advanced reading copy that still had some typos and errors. I might have gotten the finished product when I picked it up on Amazon.

I thought the characters were realistic and progressive. Maybe I was blinded by my love of free thinking progressive men and strong puzzle solving women. Aster Tanner had been an orphan and had suffered a lot of struggles. I was happy that she was in a stable place and making a living in an era when it was hard for women to do so.

I thought it was a good start to a series and I found it to be well written. This is the first of four Second Sons series. Each one of these adorable men will be getting their own story. I can’t tell you how happy I am to hear that. I really liked all four of these men. They certainly deserve their own story.

This book along with book 2 and book 3 are all available in paperback and in Kindle version on Amazon

View all my reviews

18 thoughts on “Book Review: The Cryptographer by Alice Wallis-Eton

  1. Those opening lines made me laugh. It sounds good, I’ve got to admit I haven’t read many historical novels and not one with romance…I know – where have I been? I think there’s quite a few genres I still have yet to really read lol. 😮


    1. I am always discovering new genre that I had not thought I would enjoy. Give one a try. They are so fun! I am doing an index by Genre and I realized I do read a lot of different types of books. It makes life more fun!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yes, although I have firm favourites like fantasy and SciFi I do enjoy discovering a love of a new genre. Reading for #ComedyBookWeek has made me love comedy more than I thought and I do like a good romance just never tried a historical romances yet 🙂

        Liked by 1 person

      2. I am reviewing 5 books for that week! 5! I know – insane! I was going to review 4 but then Portia Porter emailed me wanted me to do hers so now I am too!
        All you have to do for #CBW is write a review of one of the books on the list and post that review within the week 16th-23rd July. Some people are hosting interviews too but I decided to just stick with what I know I can do at the moment. If you want to take part and read and review Shizzle Inc during that week then all you have to do is email Ana: ana.spoke( at )yahoo (dot)com We need more book bloggers so it would be great if you want to join in -though you don’t have to if you don’t want to 🙂
        The list of books to review are on the main website so if you want to take a look then do, all authors give away a free digital copy of their book so it’s also a chance to get free books! lol
        If you don’t want to take part this year then there’s always next year :).

        Liked by 1 person

    2. I am already up to three books for the week lol. I think I am going to stop there. Unless that 4th author says yes lol 🙂 But I am enjoying the comedy aspect. It is going to be a fun week of reviews and interviews.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yay! And we’re part of the first ever #ComedyBookWeek! Imagine if it’s something that is really big in say ten years time! And we were part of its start :D:D lol


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s